Document Type: Original Research Paper

Authors

1 Chemistry Department, Lebanese University, Rafic Hariri Campus. El Hadath, Lebanon.

2 Faculty of Fouman, College of Engineering, University of Tehran, Fouman, Iran.

Abstract

In this work, we studied the effect of various amounts (0.2-1.2 % mole ratio) of Cu doping to TiO2 nanoparticles (Cu/TiO2) on the photocatalytic removal efficiency of the food colorant E 131 VF. Two series of doped TiO2 (P25) photocatalysts were prepared in two different media (50%ethanol-50%acetone and 5% surfactant (Tween 20)-95%H2O) by using the impregnation method. The prepared samples were characterized by XRD, FTIR, Raman, diffuse reflectance spectroscopy and SEM/EDX analyses. The XRD results showed that the crystal dimension of TiO2 increased from 23 to 35 nm and rutile/anatase ratio decreased from 16% to 9% after Cu doping in two different media. The photoactivity of TiO2 was reduced in the presence of Cu even at low molar ratio. The photocatalytic degradation rate constant of TiO2 (P25) was 0.24 (au) but it decreased to 0.015 (au) in the presence of the sample containing 0.6% Cu. Several reasons were suggested to explain the dramatic decrease in the activity of the prepared Cu/TiO2samples.

Highlights

 

Keywords

INTRODUCTION

The food products may lead to numerous problems for human health because they are containing a number of harmful organic compounds. A number of studies have focused on the use of additives and their influence on humans and on the environment[1, 2].The food colorants have been found large applications in food industry. An environmental regulation applied in most countries requires discoloring industrial wastewater prior to its discharge. A number of techniques for dyed wastewater purification based on biodegradation [3], electrochemical treatment [4, 5], adsorption [6], and advanced oxidation processes [7, 8] are suggested as solution to remediate this problem. There are some reports about using photocatalytic degradation processes for the removal of dyes from wastewater [9–11]. Photocatalytic reactions based on semiconductor nanomaterials are started by absorption of radiation with energy that equals or higher than the band-gap energy of the catalyst. The absorption promotes an electron from the valence band (VB) of the photocatalyst to the conduction band (CB), thus generating a hole (h+) in the valence band [12]. TiO2 has been found to be the most suitable and very researched material due to the high chemical stability and non-harmfulness, physical, optical and electrical properties [10, 13]. It exists in three phases: anatase, rutile, and brookite [13]. Anatase phase is mainly used as a photocatalyst but rutile phase has low catalytic activity [13]. Several efforts have been made to increase the photocatalytic efficiency of TiO2, such as doping it with metal[14–20]. The photodegradation of methyl orange (MO) was increased after doping of TiO2 with Cu[21]. Complete degradation of crystal violet (CV) was observed by Au doped TiO2, whereas for undoped TiO2 was not observed [22].The effect of metal ions on the photoactivity of TiO2 has been investigated for degradation of organic pollutants[23–25]. Some studies have suggested that improvement of the photocatalytic degradation rate was due to electron trapping by the metal ions leading to the inhibition of electron-hole recombination. However, high concentration of metal may have a detrimental effect on the photoactivity of TiO[24].The nature of the metal and the dopant concentration have remarkable effect on the photocatalytic removal of the pollutant [25]. In contrast, some studies showed that the presence of some metals such as Fe(III) and Cr(III) in TiO2 decreases the degradation rate constant of pollutants compared with pure TiO2[26].The authors explained the dramatic decrease by a progressive loss of total crystallinity, partial transition from anatase to rutile phase. There are various experimental conditions that used for doped TiO2 sample preparation and effect on photocatalytic activity, therefore experiments are necessary to point out these conditions on photocatalytic activity[15,24, 27- 28].

In this work, we prepared Cu doped TiO2 (P25) containing different amounts of Cu in two different media for the degradation of the food colorant E 131 VFThe first set samples (1st procedure) were prepared in 50% ethanol- 50% acetone; another set (2nd procedure) were prepared in 5% surfactant (Tween 20) – 95 % water. The reason for using these two media was an attempt to overcome the nanoparticles agglomeration observed when using water alone as a solvent[29]. To the author’s knowledge, use of two different media for the preparation of Cu doped TiO2 samples and investigation of their performance for degradation of the food colorant E 131 VF has not been reported yet.

EXPERIMENTAL DETAILS

TiO2 (P25) was provided from Degussa (Sigma Aldrich, Germany,) consists of 80% anatase and 20% rutile with a specific BET surface area of 50 m2 g-1 and primary particle size of 23nm. The food colorant, E131VF dye selected as an organic pollutant model, was purchased from Sigma Aldrich (C27H31N2O6S2-Na, purity: 50 %, MW:565.67 g). Cu(NO3)2 3H2O was purchased from BDH (GPR).

Preparation of Cu doped TiO2 samples

The impregnation method was selected to doping the metal according to the procedure in ref. [29].Several masses of Cu(NO3)2 3H2O (BDH, GPR) were added each time to 2 g of TiO2 in order to have samples containing 0.2-1.2 % mole ratio of Cu(II)/TiO2, and then 100 ml of equal volume of ethanol and acetone were added to each sample and stirred with a magnetic stirrer for 8 h, at room temperature. The solutions were allowed to stand at room temperature for 12 h and dried at 100 °C for another 12 h. The dried samples were ground in a mortar and annealed at 400 °C for 4h. In this impregnation method, the metal ion is deposited on the surface of TiO2[18]. Another set (2nd procedure) of the samples were also prepared with 100 ml of distilled water containing 5 ml of the surfactant Tween 20. 2 g of TiO2 followed the same steps without the addition of metal ion in order to compare it with the doped catalyst (0 %Cu/TiO2) was prepared. The prepared catalysts were named x% Cu,y, where x is the Cu/TiO2 molar ratio and y is the medium where the impregnation was done. A stock solution of E 131 VF dye was prepared by dissolving 40 mg of the dye in 1000 ml distilled water. The concentration of the dye in the experiment was selected in such a way that the absorbance of the dye followed Beer’s law.

Characterization

The X-ray diffraction patterns for crystallinity investigation were recorded on D8 Focus, Bruker, X-ray diffractometer operating at 50kV using Cu-Kα radiation (λ = 0.1541 nm). The measurement was performed over a diffraction angle range of 2θ = 10°–80°. The % of the rutile phase in the samples was determined with the following equation (Eq. 1):

Rutile (weight %) = (1)

Where IA and IR are the diffraction intensity of the anatase and rutile phases, respectively[30].

FTIR spectra of the samples were recorded on Jasco FT/IR- 6300 spectrometers in the wavenumber range of 400 to 4000 cm–1for functional groups identification. The FTIR study was performed by using KBr pellet. Raman spectra for characterization of surface functional groups were recorded on Horiba Scientific, operating with green Laser at 532 nm. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images for investigation of the morphology corresponding to the achieved specimens were taken with Ametek materials analysis division (AIS 2300C series) instrument (working distance: 25 mm, voltage 20 kV). The optical band gap energies of the prepared materials were determined by UV-Vis DRS technique using Jasco V-570 spectrophotometer.

Photocatalytic degradation tests

The degradation of the food colorant E 131 VF was followed by measuring the absorbance (A) at the maximum absorption wavelength of E 131 VF dye (640 nm) with time. UV- visible spectra were recorded on a double beam UV-visible spectrophotometer. The determination of the order of the degradation reaction and the rate constant (arbitrary unit (au)) were obtained from the curve A vs time. Prior to commencing illumination, a suspension containing 0.08 g of the catalyst and 100 ml of aqueous solution of E 131 VF dye was stirred continuously at least for 15 min in the dark (for adsorption/desorption equilibrium), then the sample was irradiated under magnetic stirring by 4 UVB lamps (λmax: 360 nm) positioned at 10 cm above the glass bowl (Luzchem LZC-4V, Canada). To quantify the decrease of the dye concentration, a sample of 3 ml was taken (with a pipette) at predetermined intervals of time and centrifuged at 4000 rpm.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Characterization of the prepared samples

The XRD patterns of TiO2 and doped TiOsamples treated at 400 °C are shown in Fig. 1. They show five primary diffractions at 2θ =25.3(100%), 38o (20 %), 48.2o(28 %) and 62.5o(10 %) which can be attributed to different planes of pure anatase form of TiO2 [20,31]. Other diffractions at 2θ = 27.36o (100%), 36o (45%), 54.0o (53 %) and 69.0o(8 %) can be attributed to pure rutile form of TiO2[32].The XRD patterns of the Cu/TiO2samples almost coincide with that of the bare TiO2(P25) or TiO2 treated at 400 °C showing no new diffractions due to cupper doping thus suggesting that the small metal ion amounts are placed on the surface of the TiO2 crystal (Fig. 1)[32]. The % of the two diffractions at 2θ= 25.3° and 27.5°of the different samples are shown in Table 1.

The average size of the TiO2 crystal was estimated by the Scherrer equation (Eq. 2) for all the samples[20] (Table 1):

 (2)

Where, D represents the mean crystal dimension, λ is the X-ray wavelength (0.1541 nm), β refers to the diffraction full width at half maximum (FWHM) in radian for diffraction at 2θ=25.3°, K represents a coefficient (0.89) and θ is the diffraction angle. The doped samples did not have the same crystal size as the untreated one (P25) due to agglomeration of tiny particles. The % of the ratio of rutile to anatase in P25 is 16 % whereas it varies between 8.3% and 9.6% for the samples prepared in the ethanol-acetone medium. The ratio of rutile/anatase of the two samples of TiO2: 0 %Cu, eth-ace and 0% Cu, surf are lower than that of the bare TiO2 whereas the particle dimension (D) is higher in both cases (Table 1).

Fig. 2 shows the FTIR spectra of TiOand Cu/TiOsamples. The FTIR spectrum of TiO2 shows three bands: broad and intense one at 3420 cm-1, the two other bands at 1620 and 620 cm-1. The peaks at 3420 and 1620 cm-1can be attributed to the O– H stretching and bending mode of hydroxyl groups of moister that is present on the surface of the catalyst [33, 34]. These are critical for photocatalytic reactions since they can react with photogenerated holes produced on the catalyst surface and generated hydroxyl radicals, which are powerful oxidant. The peaks of TiO2 observe at 476 and 620 cm-1can be assigned to the vibrations of Ti–O and Ti–O–Ti framework bonds of TiO[33]. The zoom in the region between 400 and 600 cm-1 did not show any characteristic peak of Cu-O (432.3, 497, and 603 cm-1) [35]. As the amount added of the metal salts are small, no new band and no shift is observed in the bands of the bare TiO2 after Cu doping.

In the Raman spectrum of P25, the peaks centered at 145, 396, 514 and 636 cm−1 are attributed to the anatase phase, while the peaks, located at 245, 443 and 610 cm−1 are characteristic of the rutile phase of TiO2 (Fig. 3)[35–37]. The Raman spectra of P25 and Cu/TiO2 samples consisted of characteristic peaks of anatase (Fig. 3). No shift was observed after doping with 1.2 % Cu(II) [38].As in the case of XRD, the presence of copper oxide CuO or Cu2O could not be detected by Raman spectroscopy [35]. The non-detection of the corresponding metallic oxide by these techniques (Raman, XRD, and IR) does not mean its absence, due to the small amount of copper.

The electronic band structures of the as-prepared samples were analyzed by UV–Vis diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (Fig. 4a). All the samples exhibited reflectance in the range of 250-400 nm that can be attributed to anatase and rutile phase of TiO2. The Cu-doped sample indicated a redshift extending up to 600 nm that attributed to the presence of Cu in these samples. The successful doping of Cu was also evident from the change in the color observed in the samples, shifting from pure white to light yellow. The optical band gap energy of the prepared samples was determined by UV-Vis DRS analysis[31], and the obtained DRS results are reported as the Kubelka–Munk function where R is the reflectance, F(R) is the Kubelka–Munk function (Eq. 3):

 (3)

The optical band gap energy of the samples can be derived from UV-Vis DRS data by plotting F(R) against photon energy (E: hν), followed by extrapolation of the linear part of the spectra to the energy axis(Fig. 4b)[30]. The increase in the bandgap energy of the 1.0 and 1.2 % Cu, surf samples (3.25 and 3.21 eV) with respect to that of P25 (3.12 eV) may be due to rutile/ anatase ratio in these samples. The rutile/anatase ratio is 9.3% and 9.0% for 1.0 and 1.2% Cu, surf samples and the bandgap energy for anatase and rutile phase of TiO2 are 3.20 and 3.00 eV respectively. The bandgap energy of Cu doped samples shifted to bandgap energy of pure anatase phase by decreasing rutile/anatase ratio.

SEM images of the TiO2 and 1.2 % Cu/TiO2 samples prepared in two different media are shown in Fig. 5. SEM images show that the sam­ples prepared by the two procedures are agglomerated; also the particles are bigger than the bare TiO2. The EDX patterns of Cu/TiO2 samples (Fig. 6) show two peaks around 0.2 and 4.5 keV. The intense peak is assigned to the bulk TiO2 and the less intense one to the surface TiO2[20]. The peaks of Cu are observed at 0.7, 8 and 9 keV [34]. The results confirm the existence of Cu atoms in the Cu/TiO2 samples (Table 2), but the XRD patterns did not show any diffractions related to Cu. EDX analysis shows that some zones contain high atomic % of C. It may be due to organic molecules adsorbed chemically on the surface of the TiO2nanoparticles.

Photocatalytic activity of Cu doped TiO2

The variation of the UV- visible spectrum of the dye versus time shows a decrease of all the spectra with time. The photocatalytic degradation of E 131 VF dye in the presence of the bare TiO2 follows perfectly the pseudo-first-order kinetics (Fig. 7).Also the photocatalytic degradation reaction order obtained in the presence of TiO2 with 0 % and 0.2 % Cu in the two media (calcined at 400 °C) were pseudo-first-order, but it became zero order for higher % of Cu (Fig. 7).There is a blue shift of the maximum wavelength (indicated by dotted line in Fig. 8) that proving a successive degradation of dye during irradiation. A similar result was obtained with Baraka [40]. The time needed to decrease the absorbance from 1.6 to 0.1 for the bare P25 was 12 min whereas it was 20 min for 0% Cu, eth-ace and 28 min for 0% Cu, surf. The impregnation of TiO2 in the acetone-ethanol and in the aqueous solution of surfactant affected the surface of TiO2 may be by adsorption of these organic molecules at the surface of TiO2 or by agglomeration of the nanoparticles of P25.The rate constants of TiO2 with 0 % Cu in the two media were for the 1st procedure: 0.14 and for the 2nd one:0.098,which are both smaller than the bare TiO2 (ko=0.24 (au)) and P25 heated at 400 oC without addition of any solvent for 4 h (ko=0.23 (au)) (Fig. 9).The decrease in the activity of TiO2 after solvation is due to increase in agglomeration of the nanoparticles of TiO2 and maybe also due to the adsorption of organic solute (ethanol/acetone or surfactant) on the surface of TiO2 which prevent the absorption of the radiation and therefore the good function of TiO2. The rate constant in the acetone –ethanol medium is higher than that in the surfactant medium. For higher % of Cu the rate constant ko is approximately the same (Fig. 9). For all the doped samples (including 0 % Cu), the rate constant is smaller than that of P25. The results of several works show a decrease in the photoactivity after doping with Cu(II) (Table 3). There are several factors which inhibit the photoactivity of TiO2:

1) The adsorption of the organic molecules (surfactant or ethanol) on the surface of TiO2

2) The agglomeration of the TiO2 nanoparticles during solvation, so the particles of these catalysts are not well distributed in the food colorant solution as was the case with P25. The surface area available for photon absorption would be reduced.

3) The increase in the recombination of photogenerated electrons and holes which is a function of the amount of Cu added. Paola et al. showed that the rate constants of e--h+ recombination increases when metal loading increases [22].

Proposed mechanism for E 131 VF dye degradation

Fig. 10 shows the surface of TiO2 after doping by Cu2+ in organic media and proposed mechanism for the pho­tocatalytic degradation of E 131 VF dye over Cu/TiO2 sample. High-energy electrons are formed on Cu/TiO2 surface under UV irradiation. These electrons are excited from valance band to conduction band of TiO2 and the holes remain on the valance band of TiO2. The oxygen molecules adsorbed on the sur­face of photocatalyst trap the electron from the TiOand thus a number of active species including OH and O2 radicals are produced. These species attack to E 131 VF dye molecules and decompose them. The photoinduced holes (h+) can react with H2O oxidizing them to OH radicals or oxidize the dye molecules. The reactions at the surface of photocatalyst initiating the degradation of E 131 VF dye can be expressed as follows:

Cu/TiO2+ hν → e- (CB) + h+ (VB)

O2+ e- (CB) → O2-•

H2O + h+ (VB) → OH + H+

O2-• + H+→ HOO→ OH

E 131 VF + OH → degradation of the dye

E 131 VF + h+(VB) → oxidation products

E 131 VF + e-(CB) → reduction products.

CONCLUSION

In this work, we prepared Cu doped TiO2 samples containing different amounts of Cu (0.2-1.2 % mole ratio) in two different media by impregnation method. The XRD, Raman and FTIR techniques which are bulk techniques were unable to prove the presence of small amounts of copper on the surface of TiO2, but the EDX analysis confirmed 0.5 At% of Cu. The crystal dimension of TiO2 increased in the range of 26-35nm but the rutile /anatase ratio decreased from 16% to 9% after Cu doping in two different media compared to P25. We used the prepared samples for kinetics study of the photocatalytic degradation of food colorant E 131 VF. Our obtained results showed that the doping TiO2 with Cu(II) had a detrimental effect on the photocatalytic activity of TiO2 whatever the solvent used due to agglomeration of the nanoparticles and presence of some organic molecules on TiO2 surface. The photocatalytic degradation rate constant of TiO(P25) was 0.24 (au) but it decreased to 0.015 (au) in the presence of the sample containing 0.6% Cu. We suggest studying the effect of doping to add the metal salt during the sol gel preparation of TiOin order to prevent the agglomeration of the nanoparticles.

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT

The author thanks the Lebanese University for providing financial assistance to carry out this work.

CONFLICTS OF INTEREST

There are no conflicts to declare.

 

1. Fonovich TM. Sudan dyes: are they dangerous for human health? Drug and Chemical Toxicology. 2012;36(3):343-52.

2. Inetianbor, J. E., Yakubu, J. M. and Ezeonu, S. C.: Effect of food additives and preservatives on man, a review.Asian J. Sci. Technol. 6(2), 118–1124(2015)

3. Roy DC, Biswas SK, Saha AK, Sikdar B, Rahman M, Roy AK, et al. Biodegradation of Crystal Violet dye by bacteria isolated from textile industry effluents. PeerJ. 2018;6:e5015.

4. Tabarra, M.A., Mallah,H. A., El Jamal, M. M.: Anodic oxidation of anionic xanthene dyes at Pt and BDD electrodes.J. Chem. Technol. Metall.49(3), 247–253 (2014)

5. Mallah HA, Naoufal DM, Safa AI, El-Jamal MM. Study of the Discoloration Rate of Rhodamine B as a Function of the Operating Parameters at Pt and BDD Electrodes. Portugaliae Electrochimica Acta. 2013;31(3):185-93.

6. El Jamal, M.M., Ncibi, M.C.: Biosorption of methylene blue by chaetophora elegans algae: Kinetics, equilibrium and thermodynamic studies. Acta Chim. Slov. 59(1) 24–31 (2012)

7. Vaiano V, Iervolino G, Rizzo L, Sannino D. Advanced Oxidation Processes for the Removal of Food Dyes in Wastewater. Current Organic Chemistry. 2017;21(12):1068-73.

8. Naser Elddine HA, Damaj ZK, Yazbeck OA, Tabbara MA, El-Jamal MM. Kinetic Study of the Discoloration of the Food Colorant E131 by K2S2O8 and KIO3. Portugaliae Electrochimica Acta. 2015;33(5):275-88.

9. Saquib M, Abu Tariq M, Faisal M, Muneer M. Photocatalytic degradation of two selected dye derivatives in aqueous suspensions of titanium dioxide. Desalination. 2008;219(1-3):301-11.

10. Chen C-C, Lu C-S, Mai F-D, Weng C-S. Photooxidative N-de-ethylation of anionic triarylmethane dye (sulfan blue) in titanium dioxide dispersions under UV irradiation. Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2006;137(3):1600-7.

11. Diao Z-H, Xu X-R, Liu F-M, Sun Y-X, Zhang Z-W, Sun K-F, et al. Photocatalytic degradation of malachite green by pyrite and its synergism with Cr(VI) reduction: Performance and reaction mechanism. Separation and Purification Technology. 2015;154:168-75.

12. Samsudin EM, Sze NG, Ta YW, Tan TL, Abd. Hamid SB, Joon CJ. Evaluation on the Photocatalytic Degradation Activity of Reactive Blue 4 using Pure Anatase Nano-TiO2. Sains Malaysiana. 2015;44(7):1011-9.

13. Akpan UG, Hameed BH. Parameters affecting the photocatalytic degradation of dyes using TiO2-based photocatalysts: A review. Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2009;170(2-3):520-9.

14. Tayade RJ, Kulkarni RG, Jasra RV. Transition Metal Ion Impregnated Mesoporous TiO2for Photocatalytic Degradation of Organic Contaminants in Water. Industrial & Engineering Chemistry Research. 2006;45(15):5231-8.

15. Xin B, Wang P, Ding D, Liu J, Ren Z, Fu H. Effect of surface species on Cu-TiO2 photocatalytic activity. Applied Surface Science. 2008;254(9):2569-74.

16. Liao DL, Badour CA, Liao BQ. Preparation of nanosized TiO2/ZnO composite catalyst and its photocatalytic activity for degradation of methyl orange. Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A: Chemistry. 2008;194(1):11-9.

17. Filippo E, Carlucci C, Capodilupo AL, Perulli P, Conciauro F, Corrente GA, et al. Enhanced Photocatalytic Activity of Pure Anatase Tio2 and Pt-Tio2 Nanoparticles Synthesized by Green Microwave Assisted Route. Materials Research. 2015;18(3):473-81.

18. Gupta AK, Pal A, Sahoo C. Photocatalytic degradation of a mixture of Crystal Violet (Basic Violet 3) and Methyl Red dye in aqueous suspensions using Ag+ doped TiO2. Dyes and Pigments. 2006;69(3):224-32.

19. Mahmoud, G.E.A., Ismail, L.F.M.: PhotocatalyticdegradationofDirectYellow50 onTiO2. J Am Sci. 8(10), 83–99 (2012)

20. Pirbazari AE, Monazzam P, Kisomi BF. Co/TiO2 nanoparticles: preparation, characterization and its application for photocatalytic degradation of methylene blue. DESALINATION AND WATER TREATMENT. 2017:283-92.

21. Khairy M, Zakaria W. Effect of metal-doping of TiO2 nanoparticles on their photocatalytic activities toward removal of organic dyes. Egyptian Journal of Petroleum. 2014;23(4):419-26.

22. Begum, T., Gogoi, P.K., Bora, U.: Photocatalytic degradation of crystal violet dye on the surface of Au doped TiOnanoparticles. INDIAN J. CHEM. TECHNOL. 24, 97–101 (2017)

23. Di Paola A, Garcı’a-López E, Ikeda S, Marcı’ G, Ohtani B, Palmisano L. Photocatalytic degradation of organic compounds in aqueous systems by transition metal doped polycrystalline TiO2. Catalysis Today. 2002;75(1-4):87-93.

24. Rao KVS, Lavédrine B, Boule P. Influence of metallic species on TiO2 for the photocatalytic degradation of dyes and dye intermediates. Journal of Photochemistry and Photobiology A: Chemistry. 2003;154(2-3):189-93.

25. Riaz N, Mohamad Azmi B-K, Mohd Shariff A. Iron Doped TiO2 Photocatalysts for Environmental Applications: Fundamentals and Progress. Advanced Materials Research. 2014;925:689-93.

26. Bouras P, Stathatos E, Lianos P. Pure versus metal-ion-doped nanocrystalline titania for photocatalysis. Applied Catalysis B: Environmental. 2007;73(1-2):51-9.

27. Elsalamony, R., El-Hafiza, D.A.: Influence of Preparation Method on Copper Loaded Titania Nanoparticles: Textural, Structural Properties and Its Photocatalytic Activity towards P-Nitrophenol. Chem. and Materials Res. 6(4), 122–134 (2014)

28. Di Paola A, Marcì G, Palmisano L, Schiavello M, Uosaki K, Ikeda S, et al. Preparation of Polycrystalline TiO2Photocatalysts Impregnated with Various Transition Metal Ions:  Characterization and Photocatalytic Activity for the Degradation of 4-Nitrophenol. The Journal of Physical Chemistry B. 2002;106(3):637-45.

29. El Jamal, M.M, Estephane, G.C.: Effect of Doping of TiO2 nanoparticles with Silver on their Photocatalytic Activities toward Degradation of E 131 VF. Accepted recently in J. Chem. Technol. Metall. 54 (5), 926-933 (2019).

30. Mahyar A, Amani-Ghadim AR. Influence of solvent type on the characteristics and photocatalytic activity of TiO2 nanoparticles prepared by the sol–gel method. Micro & Nano Letters. 2011;6(4):244.

31. Anku W, Osei-Bonsu Oppong S, Kumar Shukla S, Penny Govender P. Comparative photocatalytic degradation of monoazo and diazo dyes under simulated visible light using Fe3+/C/S doped-TiO2 nanoparticles. Acta Chimica Slovenica. 2016:380-91.

32. Ijadpanah-Saravy H, Safari M, Khodadadi-Darban A, Rezaei A. Synthesis of Titanium Dioxide Nanoparticles for Photocatalytic Degradation of Cyanide in Wastewater. Analytical Letters. 2014;47(10):1772-82.

33. Elsalamony, R., El-Hafiza, D.A.: Influence of Preparation Method on Copper Loaded Titania Nanoparticles: Textural, Structural Properties and Its Photocatalytic Activity towards P-Nitrophenol. 6(4), 122–134 (2014)

34. Ghasemi S, Rahimnejad S, Setayesh SR, Rohani S, Gholami MR. Transition metal ions effect on the properties and photocatalytic activity of nanocrystalline TiO2 prepared in an ionic liquid. Journal of Hazardous Materials. 2009;172(2-3):1573-8.

35. Ethiraj AS, Kang DJ. Synthesis and characterization of CuO nanowires by a simple wet chemical method. Nanoscale Research Letters. 2012;7(1).

36. Tasbihi M, Kočí K, Troppová I, Edelmannová M, Reli M, Čapek L, et al. Photocatalytic reduction of carbon dioxide over Cu/TiO2 photocatalysts. Environmental Science and Pollution Research. 2017;25(35):34903-11.

37. Wypych A, Bobowska I, Tracz M, Opasinska A, Kadlubowski S, Krzywania-Kaliszewska A, et al. Dielectric Properties and Characterisation of Titanium Dioxide Obtained by Different Chemistry Methods. Journal of Nanomaterials. 2014;2014:1-9.

38. Choudhury B, Dey M, Choudhury A. Defect generation, d-d transition, and band gap reduction in Cu-doped TiO2 nanoparticles. International Nano Letters. 2013;3(1).

39. Nguyen VN, Nguyen NKT, Nguyen PH. Hydrothermal synthesis of Fe-doped TiO2nanostructure photocatalyst. Advances in Natural Sciences: Nanoscience and Nanotechnology. 2011;2(3):035014.

40. Barka N, Qourzal S, Assabbane A, Nounah A, Ait-Ichou Y. Photocatalytic Degradation of Patent Blue V by Supported Tio2: Kinetics, Mineralization, and Reaction Pathway. Chemical Engineering Communications. 2011;198(10):1233-43.